What Counts as Evidence of Growth, Not Just Effort?
Evidence of growth is an observable change in behaviour, output, or how others respond to you. Hours spent, sessions attended, and how determined you felt are effort, not evidence. The distinction matters because it is easy to feel busy and productive while nothing measurable has moved, and it is just as easy to have changed a great deal without noticing, because the change showed up in someone else's account of you rather than your own.
This is not a call to distrust yourself. It is a call to be specific about what you are counting, and to check it against more than one source before you report a result.
Why effort gets mistaken for evidence
Effort is visible to the person doing it. You remember the calls you made, the late nights, the draft you rewrote five times. Outcomes are often visible to other people first — the client who found you easier to work with, the panel that noticed your delivery had settled, the code reviewer who stopped flagging the same issue. Self-report captures the first kind readily and the second kind poorly, because you are not well placed to observe your own effect on others in the moment.
Locke and Latham's review of goal-setting research found that specific, measurable goals outperform vague ones partly because they force this kind of clarity about what is being tracked (Locke & Latham, 2002). A goal that says "get better at client meetings" invites effort-counting. A goal that says "reduce follow-up questions raised by clients after a proposal from an average of four to two" invites evidence.
Four kinds of evidence, ranked by how much they can mislead you
| Type | Example | Risk |
|---|---|---|
| Self-rating | "I'd say my presentations are a 7 now, up from a 5" | High — prone to mood, recency, and the rater wanting to see progress |
| Artefact comparison | Recording of a talk six months ago versus last week | Medium — useful but still interpreted by one person unless reviewed by another |
| Second-party observation | A manager, mentor, or coach's independent account | Medium — depends on how much they actually see, and how consistently |
| Outcome measure | Close rate, error rate, time-to-ship, audition result | Low, if the measure is stable and not affected by unrelated factors |
No single row is sufficient on its own. Outcome measures can move for reasons that have nothing to do with the person — a market shift, a change in opponent, a different panel. Second-party observation is only as good as how much that person actually watches. The practical answer is to triangulate: hold a self-rating against at least one artefact or outside observation before deciding anything has genuinely changed.
Worked examples
A first-time manager believes their one-to-ones have improved. The effort evidence is real: they have prepared notes every week for ten weeks. The growth evidence would be a report from two or three direct reports, gathered independently, saying meetings now end with clear next steps — or a drop in the number of issues that resurface unresolved.
A founder tracking pitch delivery might feel more confident walking into investor meetings. That feeling is effort-adjacent. The evidence is a recording compared against an earlier one, reviewed by someone who was not in the room either time, plus the actual conversion rate across the last six pitches rather than the two that went well.
A professional athlete returning from injury might feel strong in training. Coaches and sports scientists generally treat subjective readiness as one input among several, alongside timed drills, load data, and match minutes, precisely because how an athlete feels and how they perform under competitive pressure are not the same thing. The same logic applies to a performing artist: feeling settled on stage and a reviewer or director noting a settled performance are different kinds of evidence, and only the second confirms the first.
A simple check before you record progress
- Name the specific thing you think has changed.
- Find one piece of evidence that is not your own impression — an artefact, a number, or someone else's account.
3.
Frequently asked questions
Is a self-rating ever good evidence?
On its own, no. Self-ratings are useful for noticing how something feels, but they are prone to recall and mood effects. Pair a self-rating with an artefact or a second-party observation before treating it as evidence of change.
Does logging hours count as evidence of growth?
No. Hours show effort or input, not outcome. A founder who spends ten hours a week on sales calls has invested time; evidence of growth would be a recorded change in close rate, call quality, or a manager's or mentor's observation of the calls themselves.
How much change counts as real growth?
Only a change larger than normal measurement error. Reliability research on minimal detectable change shows that small shifts in a rating can be noise rather than signal (NCBI, PMC5875129). If a check-in is within that margin, it is honest to record 'held steady'.
Sources
- Minimal detectable change and measurement error
- Amabile & Kramer (2011), The Power of Small Wins, HBR
Topics: Measurement · Individual Development Plan