Skip to content

Goal setting

SMART goals vs OKRs: which should an IDP use?

SMART goals, OKRs and outcome objectives compared for Individual Development Plans — what each is for, where each fails, and a hybrid that works.

By the Jobulary team · · 2 min read

The short answer

SMART goals (specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, time-bound) suit individual development because they force clarity about one outcome. OKRs (objectives and key results) suit teams aligning on ambitious shared targets. For an IDP, write an outcome-based objective that passes the SMART test, and use one or two key-result-style measures to show progress.

Two frameworks, two jobs

SMART goals — specific, measurable, achievable, relevant and time-bound — are a checklist for writing one clear target. OKRs — objectives and key results, popularised by Andy Grove at Intel and John Doerr — pair an inspiring objective with a handful of measurable results, usually to align a team or company.

Both are useful. They answer different questions.

SMART goalOKR
Best forOne person's clear targetAligning many people on shared ambition
ShapeOne statement passing five testsObjective + 2–5 key results
AmbitionAchievable by designOften stretch; partial success expected
RiskSafe, small goalsVague objectives, gamed key results

What goes wrong in development plans

The most common failure in an IDP is neither framework's fault. It is writing activities instead of outcomes: "complete the leadership course", "read three books", "attend the conference". Each can be ticked off without anything changing.

An outcome describes what will be observably different: "Two of my team leads run a full week of client delivery without escalating to me."

A hybrid that works for IDPs

  1. Write one outcome objective in plain words.
  2. Run the SMART check — especially relevant (which longer-range goal does this serve?) and time-bound (a real date).
  3. Add one or two key results that show progress along the way.
  4. List the practice, people and learning underneath — the means, not the goal.

Example for a sales professional:

  • Objective: Lead enterprise renewals end to end by March.
  • Key results: two renewals closed within budget; renewal prep calls run without the director.
  • Serves: the move from account manager to head of sales.

Report SMART gaps honestly

It is tempting to force every box to be filled. A better approach is to show which letters an objective cannot yet evidence — no measure, no date, nothing it serves — so you fix the real gap instead of typing something to satisfy a form. That is how Jobulary treats SMART: reported, never enforced.

Related: how many goals to run at once and the 70/20/10 model.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between SMART goals and OKRs?

A SMART goal is a single well-defined target. An OKR pairs a qualitative objective with a few measurable key results and is typically used to align teams on ambitious goals, often with partial achievement expected.

Can I use OKRs for personal development?

You can, but keep it small: one objective with two or three key results. The OKR habit of setting stretch targets where 70% is success can feel discouraging on a personal plan unless you say so explicitly.

What makes a development objective 'relevant'?

It visibly serves a longer-range goal — a promotion, a role change, a business target or a ranking. If an objective serves nothing longer than a quarter, ask why it is in the plan.

Sources

  1. What Matters — What is an OKR? Definition and examples
  2. Locke & Latham (2002), Building a practically useful theory of goal setting and task motivation

Topics: Goal setting · Individual Development Plan

Put this into a plan you will actually keep

Jobulary turns professional goals into at most three live commitments, sized to your week, with a first step you can take in the next seven days.

Prefer to talk it through? Book a free 30-minute meeting with a consultant