Two frameworks, two jobs
SMART goals — specific, measurable, achievable, relevant and time-bound — are a checklist for writing one clear target. OKRs — objectives and key results, popularised by Andy Grove at Intel and John Doerr — pair an inspiring objective with a handful of measurable results, usually to align a team or company.
Both are useful. They answer different questions.
| SMART goal | OKR | |
|---|---|---|
| Best for | One person's clear target | Aligning many people on shared ambition |
| Shape | One statement passing five tests | Objective + 2–5 key results |
| Ambition | Achievable by design | Often stretch; partial success expected |
| Risk | Safe, small goals | Vague objectives, gamed key results |
What goes wrong in development plans
The most common failure in an IDP is neither framework's fault. It is writing activities instead of outcomes: "complete the leadership course", "read three books", "attend the conference". Each can be ticked off without anything changing.
An outcome describes what will be observably different: "Two of my team leads run a full week of client delivery without escalating to me."
A hybrid that works for IDPs
- Write one outcome objective in plain words.
- Run the SMART check — especially relevant (which longer-range goal does this serve?) and time-bound (a real date).
- Add one or two key results that show progress along the way.
- List the practice, people and learning underneath — the means, not the goal.
Example for a sales professional:
- Objective: Lead enterprise renewals end to end by March.
- Key results: two renewals closed within budget; renewal prep calls run without the director.
- Serves: the move from account manager to head of sales.
Report SMART gaps honestly
It is tempting to force every box to be filled. A better approach is to show which letters an objective cannot yet evidence — no measure, no date, nothing it serves — so you fix the real gap instead of typing something to satisfy a form. That is how Jobulary treats SMART: reported, never enforced.
Related: how many goals to run at once and the 70/20/10 model.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between SMART goals and OKRs?
A SMART goal is a single well-defined target. An OKR pairs a qualitative objective with a few measurable key results and is typically used to align teams on ambitious goals, often with partial achievement expected.
Can I use OKRs for personal development?
You can, but keep it small: one objective with two or three key results. The OKR habit of setting stretch targets where 70% is success can feel discouraging on a personal plan unless you say so explicitly.
What makes a development objective 'relevant'?
It visibly serves a longer-range goal — a promotion, a role change, a business target or a ranking. If an objective serves nothing longer than a quarter, ask why it is in the plan.
Sources
- What Matters — What is an OKR? Definition and examples
- Locke & Latham (2002), Building a practically useful theory of goal setting and task motivation
Topics: Goal setting · Individual Development Plan